Follow Us
BSEB • Class 9 • English • Ch 15
Estimated Time: 45 Mins
Study Progress: In Progress

No Men are Foreign

Comprehensive Study Material for Bihar Board (BSEB) Class 9 English (NCERT Beehive Poem 6 / Ch 15): 'No Men Are Foreign' by James Kirkup—a moving anti-war humanist poem celebrating universal brotherhood across every border. Designed for top Bihar Board Class 9 scores, this complete study guide covers all 5 stanzas (from 'beneath all uniforms, a single body breathes', 'peaceful harvests', and 'war's long winter' to 'strength that can be won by love' and 'our hells of fire and dust'), free verse craft, poetic devices (metaphor, alliteration, repetition, enjambment), full NCERT Q1–Q4 solutions, examiner traps, and practice MCQs.

Why This Chapter Matters

Comprehensive Study Material for Bihar Board (BSEB) Class 9 English (NCERT Beehive Poem 6 / Ch 15): 'No Men Are Foreign' by James Kirkup—a moving anti-war humanist poem celebrating universal brotherhood across every border. Designed for top Bihar Board Class 9 scores, this complete study guide covers all 5 stanzas (from 'beneath all uniforms, a single body breathes', 'peaceful harvests', and 'war's long winter' to 'strength that can be won by love' and 'our hells of fire and dust'), free verse craft, poetic devices (metaphor, alliteration, repetition, enjambment), full NCERT Q1–Q4 solutions, examiner traps, and practice MCQs.

Chapter Roadmap & Progression

1 Stanzas 1–3 Text & Meaning: Single...
2 Stanzas 4–5 Text & Meaning: War Pro...
3 Poetic Form, Free Verse & Literary...
4 Central Themes: Universal Brotherho...
5 NCERT 'Thinking about the Poem' Q1–...
6 Five-Stanza Human Oneness & Similar...
7 Bihar Board Exam Strategy & 60-Seco...

Complete Concept Guide (100% Curriculum Coverage)

Stanzas 1–3 Text & Meaning: Single Body, Harvests & Love

Stanzas 1–3 Text & Analysis: Universal Brotherhood & Common Human Life

Read the opening three stanzas of James Kirkup's humanist poem No Men Are Foreign and discover the shared biological, natural, and emotional truths uniting all people on earth.

1. NCERT Text: Stanzas 1 to 3

Stanza 1: Remember, no men are strange, no countries foreign / Beneath all uniforms, a single body breathes / Like ours: the land our brothers walk upon / Is earth like this, in which we all shall lie.

Stanza 2: They, too, aware of sun and air and water, / Are fed by peaceful harvests, by war's long winter starv'd. / Their hands are ours, and in their lines we read / A labour not different from our own.

Stanza 3: Remember they have eyes like ours that wake / Or sleep, and strength that can be won / By love. In every land is common life / That all can recognise and understand.

2. Stanza-by-Stanza Detailed Explanation

Stanza 1 (Same Body, Same Earth): James Kirkup begins with an urgent moral reminder: "Remember, no men are strange, no countries foreign." Human beings draw artificial borders on maps and dress soldiers in different military uniforms (as well as distinct national and traditional clothes). Beneath those outward garments, however, beats the exact same human anatomy—a single body breathes like ours! Whether called friend or foreigner, our brothers walk upon the same earth during life and ultimately lie buried inside the same soil after death.

Stanza 2 (Shared Nature, Peace & Hard Work): Foreign citizens are equally sustained by nature's impartial gifts—sun, air, and water. During tranquil times, they eat crops from peaceful harvests just like us; during armed conflict, ordinary people on every side starve equally through the bleak scarcity of "war's long winter." Even the calloused lines across their palms reveal honest physical toil ("A labour not different from our own").

Stanza 3 (Shared Eyes, Love & Common Life): Their eyes open to morning hope and close in sleep exactly like ours. Most importantly, their inner strength is never truly conquered by bombs or brute force—it is won by love. Everywhere across continents flows one recognizable rhythm of common life built around family, work, joy, and sorrow.

Stanzas 4–5 Text & Meaning: War Propaganda & Defiled Earth

Stanzas 4–5 Text & Analysis: Why Hating Others Betrays Ourselves

Understand Kirkup's sharpest anti-war indictment: political warmongers urge hatred, yet violence destroys our own humanity and pollutes the planet we share.

1. NCERT Text: Stanzas 4 and 5

Stanza 4: Let us remember, whenever we are told / To hate our brothers, it is ourselves / That we shall dispossess, betray, condemn. / Remember, we who take arms against each other

Stanza 5: It is the human earth that we defile. / Our hells of fire and dust outrage the innocence / Of air that is everywhere our own, / Remember, no men are foreign, and no countries strange.

2. Line-by-Line Anti-War Breakdown

Who Tells Us to Hate? (NCERT Q4): Selfish politicians, power-hungry leaders, and propagandists often manipulate citizens during border tensions or wartime, urging them to view neighbouring people as enemies. Kirkup warns us clearly: if we obey blindly and hate our fellow human beings, we end up harming ourselves! We dispossess (deprive ourselves of shared peace and fellowship), betray (break faith with our own conscience and common humanity), and condemn (pass moral guilt upon our own race).

Defiling the Shared Earth & Innocent Air: Notice how Stanza 4 runs directly into Stanza 5 through enjambment: whenever armies take arms against each other, it is the single shared human earth that gets polluted and bloodied (defile). Weapons, bombs, smoke, and ash create literal "hells of fire and dust" that violate (outrage) the pure, guiltless sky—the "innocence of air that is everywhere our own."

Notice the Cyclic Inversion in the Closing Line!

Line 1 opens with: "Remember, no men are strange, no countries foreign." Line 20 closes with the reversed mirror: "Remember, no men are foreign, and no countries strange." Swapping the adjectives proves that both labels ("strange" and "foreign") are equally hollow illusions!

Key Anti-War Takeaway from Stanzas 4–5

James Kirkup refuses to blame ordinary soldiers; instead he blames selfish war-mongers and urges ordinary citizens everywhere to recognize that destroying another nation's children destroys our own collective future.

Poetic Form, Free Verse & Literary Devices Laboratory

Form, Free Verse Rhythm & Poetic Devices Mastery

Every Bihar Board extract question asks why there is no rhyme scheme and which literary devices make Kirkup's peace plea unforgettable.

1. Structural Form: Five Unrhymed Quatrains (Free Verse)

Unlike musical ballads or rhyming lyrics, No Men Are Foreign is composed in free verse across five balanced four-line stanzas (20 lines) with no fixed rhyme scheme. Why did James Kirkup reject rigid rhyme and artificial metre? Just as national borders artificially divide one human family, strict rhyme schemes constrain natural speech. Free verse lets the poem read like an earnest, heartfelt moral appeal spoken directly by one global citizen to another.

2. Complete Poetic Devices Table (With Exact Textual Proof)

Poetic Device Exact Line / Example How It Works for Full Marks
Repetition & Cyclic Frame "Remember..." (5 times); Line 1 vs. Line 20 inversion Acts like a conscience bell reminding readers not to fall for divisive hate propaganda; encloses the entire poem in a unified peace frame.
Metaphor (Uniforms) "Beneath all uniforms, a single body breathes" Implicitly treats national military uniforms and cultural dress as mere outer coverings hiding identical human beings.
Metaphor (War's Winter) "by war's long winter starv'd" Compares the famine, cold cruelty, and barrenness of wartime directly to a harsh, endless winter season.
Metaphor (Hells of Fire) "Our hells of fire and dust outrage the innocence" Compares warfare, explosions, smoke, and nuclear/artillery devastation to hell tormenting pure, innocent nature.
Alliteration "body breathes" ('b'); "war's... winter" ('w'); "sleeps... strength" ('s') Gives urgent spoken emphasis and rhythmic cohesion even within unrhymed free verse.
Enjambment Stanzas 1–5 (e.g. Stanza 4 line 4 running directly into Stanza 5 line 1) Carries syntax smoothly across line and stanza boundaries without punctuation pauses, showing unbroken human connection.

Central Themes: Universal Brotherhood & Peace vs. War

Core Themes, Humanism & Environmental Anti-War Message

Master the philosophical pillars of Kirkup's anti-war masterpiece to write high-scoring 4–5 mark value-based answers in Bihar Board Class 9 exams.

1. Four Core Philosophical Themes

  • Universal Brotherhood & Equality: Every human breathes the same air, walks the same planet, wakes and sleeps with identical eyes, works with equal labour, and returns to the same soil after death. National flags and uniforms never change our shared biological and moral essence.
  • Critique of Divisive Propaganda: Hatred is not natural; people are "told to hate our brothers" by narrow political or warmongering interests. Refusing blind obedience protects human dignity.
  • War Is Collective Self-Harm: Picking up arms against another country means we dispossess, betray, and condemn ourselves—because harming another member of the human family wounds our own collective survival.
  • Ecological Cost of Warfare: Bombs, firestorms, and toxic smoke do not obey country lines; they defile the single human earth and outrage the innocence of air breathed by innocent children everywhere.

2. Peace vs. War — Thematic Contrast Table

Dimension In Times of Peace & Love In Times of Hatred & War
Nourishment Fed abundantly by shared, peaceful harvests Starved equally by war's long winter
Human Bonds Strength won gently through mutual love & common life Self-dispossession, betrayal, and mutual condemnation
Environment Pure sunlight, fertile earth, clean water, innocent air Human earth defiled by hells of fire and dust

NCERT 'Thinking about the Poem' Q1–Q4 & Word Bank

NCERT 'Thinking about the Poem' Solutions & Word Bank

Concise, textbook-verified answers to all four NCERT questions plus the high-frequency vocabulary tested in objective MCQs.

1. NCERT Textbook Questions Q1–Q4 Snapshot

Q1 (Uniforms & Equality): "Uniforms" refers to different military uniforms worn by armies worldwide as well as diverse national dresses. Underneath those outer appearances, every human shares one identical body that breathes, walks on the same earth, and lies buried in it after death.

Q2 (Five Ways We Are Alike in Stanza 1): (1) Beneath uniforms a single body breathes; (2) that body breathes like ours; (3) we walk on the same land; (4) the earth they tread is just like ours; (5) in the same earth we all shall lie after death.

Q3 (Common Features in Stanza 2): Awareness of shared sun, air, and water; nourishment by peaceful harvests (and starvation in war's long winter); identical hands showing lines of hard labour not different from our own.

Q4 ("Told to hate our brothers"): Selfish politicians and warmongers provoke hatred during conflicts for personal gain. We must refuse them because hating and fighting fellow humans betrays and condemns ourselves while polluting our own earth and air.

2. Key Vocabulary & Contextual Meanings

  • Uniforms: Distinct military/army dresses worn by soldiers of different nations.
  • Dispossess: Deprive, dislodge, or strip someone (here, ourselves) of rightful peace and brotherhood.
  • Betray / Condemn: Be disloyal to our own humanity and declare ourselves morally guilty.
  • Defile: Make impure, pollute, or desecrate the shared earth through bloodshed and war.
  • Outrage the innocence: Violate or spoil the pure, unpolluted sky with war's smoke, fire, and ash.

3. High-Scoring Extract & Inference Checklist

Notice how NCERT Question 2 specifically asks for five ways from Stanza 1 alone: never mix Stanza 2 words like harvests or hands into a Stanza 1 answer! Keep biological breathing, shared walking land, shared soil, and eventual burial together as your five Stanza 1 proofs, and reserve sun, air, water, crops, and labour strictly for Stanza 2 (NCERT Q3).

Five-Stanza Human Oneness & Similarities Matrix

Similarities Matrix: Proving Human Oneness Across All Five Stanzas

Organize every stanza's exact textual evidence into one quick comparison table for effortless extract-based and short-answer recall.

1. Five-Stanza Evidence Progression

Stanza What Unites All Humanity? Key Board Words to Quote
Stanza 1 Biological body, breath, shared earth in life and burial in death "Beneath all uniforms, a single body breathes"
Stanza 2 Dependence on nature, harvests, wartime hunger, and manual labour "peaceful harvests", "war's long winter", "labour"
Stanza 3 Waking/sleeping eyes, responsiveness to love, common everyday life "strength that can be won / By love"
Stanza 4 Moral unity: hating another harms only our own selves "dispossess, betray, condemn"
Stanza 5 Environmental unity: shared biosphere poisoned by war's fire & dust "defile", "outrage the innocence of air"

Why Hands Have "Lines" Like Ours (Stanza 2 Clue)

In lines 7–8 ("Their hands are ours, and in their lines we read / A labour not different from our own"), hard physical toil etches creases into every worker's palms worldwide—proving working people across countries endure identical daily struggles.

Bihar Board Exam Strategy & 60-Second Self-Test

Bihar Board Exam Readiness Blueprint & 60-Second Self-Test

Lock in full marks on Bihar Board objective MCQs, extract passages, and 5-mark essays with these final exam tactics.

1. High-Yield Bihar Board Writing Rules

  • Always Name Poet & Form First: Open extract or summary answers cleanly: "These lines are taken from 'No Men Are Foreign', a free-verse humanist poem written by James Kirkup."
  • Never Guess a Rhyme Scheme: If asked for the rhyme scheme, write explicitly that there is no rhyme scheme because the poem uses free verse.
  • Quote All Three Self-Harm Verbs Together: Writing "dispossess, betray, condemn" in Stanza 4 answers guarantees instant examiner credit.
  • Pair Human Harm With Ecological Harm: For any long answer on the effects of war, mention both moral betrayal (Stanza 4) and pollution of earth and air (Stanza 5).

2. Rapid Pre-Exam Self-Check (5 Quick Prompts)

1. How many times does the command "Remember" appear? -> Five times (opening Stanzas 1, 3, 4 line 1, 4 line 4, and closing line 20).

2. By what gentle power can human strength be won (Stanza 3)? -> By love, never by hatred or violence.

3. What poetic device is "war's long winter"? -> Metaphor (+ Alliteration in w/w).

4. What do "hells of fire and dust" violate? -> The innocence of air that belongs to everyone.

5. How does line 20 differ from line 1? -> It reverses strange and foreign ("no men are foreign, and no countries strange").

3. Common Board Extract Prompts & Opening Lines

Board Prompt Pattern Ideal Scoring Angle
Title Justification Explain how identical breath, earth, sunlight, labour, and capacity for love make borders illusory.
"Hells of Fire and Dust" Link warfare explosions and smoke directly to global air pollution harming all humanity equally.

Conceptual Solved Examples & Case Studies

Example 1
What does the poet mean by 'uniforms' in Stanza 1, and what lies beneath them?
Step-by-Step Solution:
Example 2
According to Stanza 2, how are people across different countries united during peace and during war?
Step-by-Step Solution:
Example 3
Identify three poetic devices in 'Our hells of fire and dust outrage the innocence / Of air that is everywhere our own' along with its rhyme style.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Example 4
Who tells us to hate our brothers, and why does James Kirkup warn us against obeying them?
Step-by-Step Solution:
Example 5
Find five ways from Stanza 1 in which all human beings are alike, quoting the poet's words.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Example 6
Discuss the central message of universal brotherhood and anti-war humanism in 'No Men Are Foreign'.
Step-by-Step Solution:

Common Misconceptions & Examiner Traps

Common Misconception

Scientific Reality & Correction

State clearly that 'No Men Are Foreign' is written in unrhymed Free Verse with NO rhyme scheme.

Common Misconception

Scientific Reality & Correction

Explain that politically countries exist, but humanly all people share one body, earth, and common life.

Common Misconception

Scientific Reality & Correction

Identify 'war's long winter' as a Metaphor for wartime famine, hardship, and prolonged human suffering.

Common Misconception

Scientific Reality & Correction

Conclude war-effect answers with how bombs and 'hells of fire and dust' poison everyone's shared air and earth.

Common Misconception

Scientific Reality & Correction

Quote Line 20 accurately as 'Remember, no men are foreign, and no countries strange.'

Chapter Summary & 10 Key Takeaways

Takeaway 1
James Kirkup's moving free-verse poem 'No Men Are Foreign' delivers an urgent plea for universal human brotherhood and peace across man-made borders. Framing its five unrhymed quatrains cyclically between 'Remember, no men are strange, no countries foreign' and its mirrored closing reversal, the poet dismantles every excuse for hatred and war. Beneath outer military uniforms or regional costumes breathes a single shared human body that walks upon the same earth and eventually lies buried inside it. People across all nations enjoy the same sun, air, and water—fed equally by 'peaceful harvests' and starved together during the bleak famine of 'war's long winter.' Their palms reveal honest physical labour identical to ours, their eyes wake and sleep like ours, and their inner strength yields only to love. Kirkup warns strongly that whenever selfish warmongers urge us to hate our brothers, violence inflicts self-harm: we dispossess, betray, and condemn ourselves while polluting ('defiling') the human earth and outraging the 'innocence of air' with 'hells of fire and dust.' Using sharp metaphors, alliteration, enjambment, and repeated reminders, the poem reminds students that safeguarding peace preserves all humanity.

Check Your Understanding (Diagnostic Practice Questions)

Diagnostic questions testing core conceptual clarity. Answers are hidden initially — solve each problem first, then click to reveal the step-by-step verified solution.

1
What poetic form and rhyme scheme does James Kirkup use in 'No Men Are Foreign'?
Reveal Answer & Explanation
Answer: Free verse with no fixed rhyme scheme
Check Stanza 1 end words: foreign / breathes / upon / lie — none of them rhyme!
2
According to Stanza 3, by what means can human 'strength' truly be won?
Reveal Answer & Explanation
Answer: By love

Read lines 10–11: '...and strength that can be won / By ____.'

3
What does the metaphor 'war's long winter' stand for in Stanza 2?
Reveal Answer & Explanation
Answer: Harsh scarcity, hunger, and prolonged suffering caused by war
Contrast it directly with 'fed by peaceful harvests' in the very same line!
4
Whom do we actually harm whenever we obey orders to 'hate our brothers'?
Reveal Answer & Explanation
Answer: Ourselves — we dispossess, betray, and condemn ourselves

Look closely at Stanza 4 lines 14–15: '...it is ourselves / That we shall ______.'

5
What do 'hells of fire and dust' do in the closing stanza of the poem?
Reveal Answer & Explanation
Answer: Defile the human earth and outrage the innocence of shared air
Notice Stanza 5 focuses on pollution of earth and air caused by warfare.
Finished Studying This Chapter?
READY TO PRACTICE?

Timed CBT Practice Tests (Exam Simulator)

Put your concepts to the test with official curriculum-aligned Foundation and Advanced practice tests. Get instant accuracy scores, time metrics, and step-by-step verified explanations.

STAY UPDATED

Get the Latest Updates

New test series, syllabus updates, exam notifications and more.

Syllabus
Updates
Exam
Alerts
Study
Resources