Story Part I: Lushkoff's Lies, Advocate Sergei & the Woodshed Encounter
Understand how a broken former choir singer is caught lying by a sharp advocate and pulled reluctantly into a woodshed—where cook Olga watches angrily.
1. The Pitiful Plea & Caught Red-Handed (NCERT Q1 & Q2)
- The Ragged Stranger: A middle-aged beggar wearing a tattered fawn-coloured overcoat approached prosperous advocate Sergei, pleading with dull, drunken eyes and a red spot on either cheek. He claimed to have been a village schoolteacher for eight years who lost his post through intrigues and now held an offer in the province of Kaluga, yet lacked travel fare.
- The Mismatched Overshoes Clues: Looking sharply at the mendicant's feet—wearing one high overshoe and one low—Sergei exploded in anger! Just two days earlier in Sadovya Street, this exact beggar had told Sergei he was a starving, expelled student (`not a village schoolteacher`), even threatening to call police!
- Why Lushkoff Invented Lies (NCERT Q2): Trapped without escape, the beggar confessed his real name, Lushkoff, and his bitter truth: he had sung in a Russian choir until dismissed for chronic drunkenness. He lied openly because "nobody will give me anything when I tell the truth—what can I do? I can't get along without lying."
2. Forced Into Wood-Chopping Out of Pride & Shame (NCERT Q3)
Refusing to reward idleness with idle charity, Sergei challenged Lushkoff cleanly: "Very well, I'll give you work—will you chop wood for me?" Weakened by heavy vodka and far from being a willing worker, Lushkoff still said yes solely because he had been trapped by his own words and felt pride and shame after his humiliation before the wealthy lawyer. Leading him quickly to the dining-room door, Sergei handed him over strictly to his cook, Olga, ordering her to show the beggar into the courtyard shed.
3. The Scene Inside the Woodshed (Observed Through Window)
Watching from his dining-room window, Sergei saw Lushkoff totter stiffly across snow in the yard looking cold and sick. Glaring fiercely across her shoulder, Olga unlocked the woodshed, flung an axe angrily down at his feet, spat in disgust, and scolded him mercilessly as a drunkard. Lushkoff sat helplessly on a block of wood and held a billet clumsily between his knees without striking well—leaving Sergei ashamed of forcing a sick drunkard into bitter winter toil.