Stanzas 1–2 Text & Analysis: Why a Simple Knife Jab Cannot Kill a Tree
Read the first two stanzas of Gieve Patel's ironic poem On Killing a Tree and discover why years of underground nourishment make a mature tree extraordinarily hard to destroy.
1. NCERT Text: Stanzas 1 and 2
Stanza 1: It takes much time to kill a tree, / Not a simple jab of the knife / Will do it. It has grown / Slowly consuming the earth, / Rising out of it, feeding / Upon its crust, absorbing / Years of sunlight, air, water, / And out of its leprous hide / Sprouting leaves.
Stanza 2: So hack and chop / But this alone wont do it— / Not so much pain will do it: / The bleeding bark will heal, / And from close to the ground / Will rise curled green twigs, / Miniature boughs / Which if unchecked will expand again / To former size.
2. Line-by-Line Detailed Explanation
Stanza 1 (Slow, Patient Growth): Opening like a calm, chilling manual, Gieve Patel states plainly: "It takes much time to kill a tree." A hasty cut or "simple jab of the knife" never finishes off a mature tree. Over long decades, the tree has grown patiently by consuming the earth, rising gradually above ground, feeding upon the soil's upper crust, and absorbing countless years of sunlight, air, and water. Even out of its rough, uneven, patchy bark—metaphorically termed "leprous hide" because it resembles scarred skin—vital life keeps pushing out fresh green sprouting leaves.
Stanza 2 (Hacking & Miraculous Regeneration): Even brutal axe blows ("So hack and chop") fail to finish the tree off! Although intense pain makes sap ooze from wounded wood like human blood ("the bleeding bark"), the tree treats its own injury and recovers. Soon, tender curled green twigs and tiny new branches (miniature boughs) sprout right near the stump—and if left uncut (unchecked), those tiny shoots expand gradually back into the towering tree's former size!
NCERT Q2 Quick Lock — Five Phrases Showing Tree Growth
Quote these five active phrases from Stanza 1: (1) Slowly consuming the earth, (2) Rising out of it, (3) feeding upon its crust, (4) absorbing years of sunlight, air, water, and (5) sprouting leaves.