To investigate the internal distribution of mass and charge within atoms, Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden, under the direction of Ernest Rutherford, directed a highly collimated beam of energetic 5.5 MeV alpha particles (⁴₂He²⁺ nuclei emitted from a bismuth radioactive source ²¹⁴₈₃Bi encased in a lead block) onto an ultra-thin gold foil of thickness approximately 2.1 × 10⁻⁷ m (roughly 1,000 atomic layers). Scattered alpha particles were detected using a rotatable zinc sulfide (ZnS) fluorescent screen coupled to a low-power viewing microscope.
The experimental observations yielded three startling conclusions that shattered J.J. Thomson's classical 'plum pudding' model:
- Unimpeded Transmission: Approximately
99.86%of the incident alpha particles passed straight through the foil with deflections of less than1°, proving that the vast majority of atomic volume is completely empty space. - Large-Angle Deflections: A tiny fraction (about
0.14%) were scattered through angles greater than1°, and roughly1 in 8,000particles was deflected by more than90°. - Backscattering: Extremely rare alpha particles suffered backward rebound deflections approaching
180°, demonstrating that the entire positive charge and virtually all the mass of the atom is concentrated into a vanishingly small, dense central core termed the Nucleus.
The Impact Parameter (b) is defined as the perpendicular distance between the initial velocity vector of the incoming alpha particle and the central line passing through the center of the target nucleus. By balancing Coulomb repulsive electrostatic forces with Newtonian trajectory mechanics, the scattering angle θ is related to b by:
Key physical interpretations:
- For large impact parameters (
b >> R_nucleus), Coulomb repulsion is weak, yielding grazing collisions and very small scattering angles (θ ≈ 0°). - For small impact parameters (
b → 0), the alpha particle experiences intense electrostatic repulsion, suffering massive deflection. For a direct head-on collision (b = 0),cot(θ/2) = 0 ⟹ θ = 180°(complete reversal).
In a direct head-on collision (θ = 180°), an alpha particle approaches the gold nucleus along the central axis, decelerates under repulsive Coulomb forces, momentarily comes to rest at the Distance of Closest Approach (r₀), and rebounds. At this turning point, the initial kinetic energy K_α is entirely converted into electrostatic potential energy U:
For a typical 7.7 MeV alpha particle directed at a gold nucleus (Z = 79):
Because the alpha particle turns back before penetrating the nuclear surface, the actual radius of the gold nucleus must be strictly smaller than 30 fm, establishing an upper limit for nuclear dimensions (typically ~ 10⁻¹⁵ to 10⁻¹⁴ m).
- Orbital Instability: According to Maxwellian classical electromagnetic theory, an electron revolving in a circular orbit experiences continuous centripetal acceleration (
a = v²/r). Accelerating charges must continuously radiate electromagnetic energy. Consequently, the orbiting electron would lose kinetic energy, spiraling inward along a contracting path and collapsing into the nucleus within approximately10⁻⁸ seconds. Hence, Rutherford's classical model cannot account for atomic stability. - Inability to Explain Discrete Line Spectra: As the spiraling electron's orbital frequency continuously changes, it should emit electromagnetic radiation across a continuous spectrum of all wavelengths. In reality, atoms emit sharp, discrete line spectra with highly specific, quantized frequencies.